Why Top Grades and Test Scores Aren’t Enough Anymore
A Reality Check on College Admissions: Be MORE than a Number
Every year, there are high-achieving students who have done everything “right”: earned stellar grades, scored well on standardized tests, and stayed out of trouble. And yet, when application season rolls around, many are shocked when those dream schools — the ones with the prestigious names and single-digit admit rates — don’t say “Yes.”
It’s not because these students aren’t smart or capable. Quite the opposite. But, here’s the truth that’s difficult for many families to fully grasp:
Being a great student isn’t rare anymore.
Let’s start with the numbers.
There are over 26,000 public and private high schools in the United States. That means there are tens of thousands of valedictorians and salutatorians every year — and far more students in the top 5–10% of their classes who may not have a perfect GPA but are exceptional in leadership, service, creativity, research, and other dimensions of growth.
Now picture all of those students — plus top applicants from around the world — vying for the same small number of spots at a handful of elite colleges.
Consider:
Georgia Tech had an out-of-state acceptance rate of 9% in the most recent admissions cycle.
UVA admits fewer than 15% of out-of-state applicants during Early Action.
Rice University, a private institution, accepts fewer than 9% of applicants overall.
Those statistics don’t reflect just any students — they reflect thousands of highly qualified students with strong transcripts and test scores. If a student is relying on grades and scores alone, even if those grades are near-perfect, they’re competing in a pool full of students just like them. In other words:
A high GPA and a strong ACT or SAT score might open the door — but they rarely walk you through it.
In today’s admissions landscape, what truly differentiates students is what they’ve chosen to do with their time and interests:
Have they pursued meaningful projects or independent research?
Have they taken summer enrichment programs that deepened their academic passions?
Have they connected with mentors or teachers in their intended field?
Have they shown initiative, curiosity, or a desire to build something that didn’t exist before?
These are not bonus points. These are increasingly essential for standing out in a sea of excellence.
There’s no shame in being “just” a great student — but in the most competitive admissions processes, that alone often isn’t enough. Particularly in an era of significant grade inflation, colleges are paying closer attention to the story behind the student: how they’ve demonstrated growth, engagement, initiative, and real-world readiness.
As counselors, educators, and parents, we can provide resources, encouragement, and opportunities — but students have to choose to act. If they don’t, that’s part of their learning too.
Sometimes, not getting into that dream school is exactly the moment a student begins to understand the value of pushing beyond comfort.
Because in the end, college admissions isn’t just about getting in — it’s about growing up.
Are you in need of application assistance? How about help with college selection, essay writing or admissions interview prep? Let us know!
Follow us on Instagram! @thecarnahangroupllc
