The Elusive “Character” Quality in College Admissions

Sep 1

The idea of building and demonstrating “Character” in your college application can feel so broad. How do you narrow this down? What it is exactly that colleges expect to see?

The character component in college admissions is an elusive but critical element that can significantly impact a student’s application. As colleges increasingly look for personal qualities that align with their values and mission, families often find it challenging to grasp what “character” entails and how students can effectively demonstrate it. Recent research by NACAC and the Character Collaborative also highlight the growing emphasis on character traits in admissions decisions, particularly at selective colleges. Below, we’ll explore what character means in the admissions process and provide actionable insights on how students can showcase their character strengths.

1. Why Character Matters in Admissions

A 2019 study by the National Association for College Admissions Counseling (NACAC) found that private and selective colleges place significant value on character traits. Attributes like resilience, integrity and collaboration help institutions build classes that reflect their mission, creating a community of engaged and ethical learners.

Predictor of Success: Character attributes are linked to long-term success in academics and life.
Institutional Alignment: Colleges seek students whose personal qualities align with their mission and values.
Increasing Significance: Surveys indicate that positive character attributes rank alongside essays and extracurriculars in importance for admissions.

2. What Are Character Traits Colleges Look For?

According to NACAC, these traits are increasingly evaluated through essays, recommendations and extracurricular activities. Highlighting them authentically helps applicants stand out, particularly in competitive admissions processes.

Resilience: Overcoming adversity and demonstrating grit.
Integrity: Honesty and ethical behavior.
Empathy: Understanding and supporting others.
Curiosity: A drive for learning and exploring new ideas.
Civic Responsibility: Commitment to community improvement.
Collaboration: Teamwork and the ability to unite diverse perspectives.

3. How Colleges Assess Character

NACAC research shows that essays and recommendations are primary tools for assessing character. Colleges often train admissions officers to look for examples of resilience, ethical decision-making, and other key traits within these materials.

Essays and Personal Statements: The most common tool for evaluating character.
Teacher and Counselor Recommendations: Insights into integrity, empathy and collaboration.
Extracurricular Activities: Evidence of leadership, persistence and community engagement.
Interviews: Direct opportunities to discuss character-related experiences.

4. Strategies for Demonstrating Character in Applications

Authenticity is crucial. Admissions officers value genuine narratives that demonstrate growth and self-awareness. Highlighting involvement in character-building programs or activities can also reinforce your application.

Tell a Story: Use personal anecdotes to illustrate key traits.
Choose Recommenders Wisely: Select individuals who can provide specific examples of your character.
Highlight Meaningful Activities: Showcase sustained commitment to causes or projects.
Be Reflective: Share lessons learned from challenges or successes.

5. The Role of Schools in Character Development

According to NACAC, 58% of secondary schools offer formal character development programs. Students should take advantage of these opportunities to build and showcase their personal strengths.

Formal Programs: Many secondary schools incorporate character education into curricula or extracurriculars.
Recognition Systems: Schools often recognize students for demonstrating positive traits.
Variability: Implementation and emphasis on character education differ widely among schools.

Zooming Out to the Bigger Picture

The growing emphasis on character in college admissions reflects a broader shift toward holistic applicant evaluation. By understanding what colleges value and thoughtfully presenting their unique traits, students can enhance their applications and contribute meaningfully to their future college communities.

Click here to learn more about NACAC’s “Character Focus Initiative.”